Its 2023! And I have updated the list!
If you have a larger family or older kids who love to eat, a 2-slice toaster is not going to help you! You don’t want to be stuck in the kitchen making toast while the others are enjoying breakfast. A toaster should make your life easier and a 4 slice toaster will do just that.
You want a model that browns evenly, has adjustable shade settings, and a crumb tray. Having extra features like defrost, cancel, and bagel are an added bonus. And, when it comes to 4 slice toasters, you want the option of having dual functions on either side. It is great to defrost on one side and toast bagels on the other!
4 slice toasters do take up more space than their smaller 2-slice models. They are often more expensive and the more expensive models come with fancy touch screens options.
My reviews below will help you make a decision on which 4 slice toaster is best for you. If you are in a hurry and don’t like reading, skip down to ‘My Top 4 Slice Toaster Suggestions’ or ‘Which 4 Slice Toaster is Best For Me’.
Cuisinart 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster
This stylish and compact toaster comes from a very popular brand name, Cuisinart. Their products are fast becoming a top choice for durability, style and ease of use. This toaster has over 27000 good reviews on Amazon, so I am sold!
This model offers versatile toasting functions such as Toast, Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Cancel. There are 7 shades of browning from light to medium, and dark to suit all tastes.
I love that it has a compact design but still offers 1.5-inch wide slots which allow for toasting of bagels, muffins, artisan breads, and toaster treats. This is not a digital toaster! Functions are selected by pressing classic buttons or turning a dial. Great for people who still want to stay away from touchscreens.
You can operate either side of the toaster separately, so toast 2 slices to dark on one side and 2 slices to light on the other, simultaneously. How cool is that? To get the toast out without burning your fingers, there is a high-lift lever on either side to pop up the toast.
This model has a removable crumb tray and a fabulous cord wrap so you can keep those cables out of sight when the toaster is not in use. All round, a great choice for any kitchen. It also comes with a Limited 3-Year Warranty.
A Quick Look
- 4 slice toaster
- Easy-to-use button and dial controls
- Bagel, defrost, reheat functions
- 1.5 inch wide slots for toasting bagels and muffins
- 7 browning levels
- Removable crumb tray
- High lift lever
What We Like
- Renowned brand name
- Classic black color
- Wide slots for bagels, muffins, and artisan breads
- Crumb tray and cord wrap for neat kitchen counters
What We Don't Like
- Some people may not like plastic toasters and prefer a stainless steel model
Amazon Basics 4-Slot Toaster, White
I always like to recommend an Amazon Basics device. They are marketed as ‘highly rated products at low prices’. If you are in the market for a simple toaster that functions well, go for an Amazon Basics. The price is also great for this 4-slice toaster at under $50.
This model offers 4 separate slots that operate in sets of two, independently of one another. That means you can toast on one side and defrost on the other at the same time. Very handy when you are trying to make breakfast for a lot of hungry people.
The toaster offers wider slots that can hold bagels, English muffins, artisan breads, and waffles. The bagel function will toast on one side and keep the other warm. This toaster has 6 levels of browning to suit all tastes. The levels are selected by turning a neat easy-to-use knob that clicks past each setting. It also offers a cancel function and a defrost function.
If you don’t enjoy having your appliance cords lying around on the counter, the toaster has a handy cord wrap that keeps the cord out of sight when not in use.
A Quick Look
- Basic 4 slice toaster from Amazon basics
- Extra-wide slots for toasting bagels
- 6 browning settings
- Cancel and defrost settings
- 2 removable crumb trays
What We Like
- Less expensive toaster for a larger family
- 6 browning settings
- Handy cancel and defrost functions
- Crumb trays and cord wrap for neat kitchen counters
What We Don't Like
- This is a cheaper model and may not last for years
- Some users complained that the plastic smell remained for many weeks
Mueller UltraToast, Toaster 4 Slice, Long Wide Slots
The Mueller UltraToast, Toaster 4 Slice, Long Wide Slots is a great choice if you are looking for a brand name and great value for money. It offers many features usually only found on far more expensive toasters.
It has 2 long slots instead of the usual 4 slots. Long slots are great if you want to toast homemade breads and speciality breads that are cut into long slimmer slices. You have 6 browning settings that will suit all tastes. There is a simple LED count-down timer that shows you how much longer your toast will take. For people who get stressed out by LED displays, don’t panic – this is a very simple one that is very handy.
The slots are extra wide, making it ideal for toasting Texas toast, bagels, English muffins, and waffles. You have a Defrost function that will defrost and toast in one step. There is also a reheat button, great for warming up your toast when you got sidetracked and forgot about it.
A cool feature that you usually only find on more expensive toasters is the warming rack. The rack is built-in and allows you to warm croissants, bread rolls, buns, and baguettes in a jiffy. This is a well-priced 4-slice toaster under $50.
A Quick Look
- Stylish 4 slice toaster
- 2 long slots
- Extra-wide slots for toasting bagels
- 6 browning settings
- Cancel, reheat, and defrost settings
- Built-in warming rack
- Removable crumb tray
- Base cord storage
What We Like
- Great features at a good price
- 6 browning settings
- 2 long slots for artisan breads
- Cancel, reheat, and defrost functions
- Warming tray
- Crumb tray and cord wrap for neat kitchen counters
What We Don't Like
- Some people prefer 4 separate slots
- No separate controls per side
Buydeem 4-Slice Toaster
If you are serious about toasted bagels, this is the 4 slice toaster for you. Many toasters with bagel settings toast on the cut side only, and some claim to have bagel settings but do nothing more than toast both sides. The Buydeem DT640 4-Slice Toaster has it all figured out. It first warms up both sides of the bagel and then toasts the cut side. Now, that makes sense to me!
This toaster is ideal for a family, offering 4 slots that work in sets of 2, independently from one another. You can make toast on side and bagels on the other, or you can toast on one side and defrost on the other. A great way to keep everyone happy at the breakfast table.
The slots are 1.4 inches wide, ideal for speciality breads, muffins, waffles and Texas toast. There are 7 browning settings that are easily selected via a knob. The toaster also has centering guides, so that your toast comes out the same shade on both sides. Also included are cancel and reheat options.
Although it is a 4-slice toaster, it does have a neat compact design ideal for kitchens that have less space. I love the color choices. There is classic stainless steel, and you have a choice of retro Cozy Greenish and retro Mellow Yellow. This is a good choice toaster for under $50.
A Quick Look
- 4 slice toaster with independent side controls
- Compact design
- Cool color choice in Stainless Steel, Cozy Greenish, and Mellow Yellow
- Bagel setting warms both sides and then toasts the cut side
- Extra-wide slots for toasting bagels and artisan breads
- 7 shade settings
- Cancel, defrost, and bagel settings
- Solid high-lift lever
What We Like
- Stylish compact design
- Fun color choice for retro-style kitchens
- Wide slots for bagels, muffins, and artisan breads
- Bagel setting warms both sides and then toasts the cut side
- Cancel and defrost functions
- Easy-to-remove crumb tray
What We Don't Like
- No mention of a cool-touch exterior
- Markings on the knob are not color contrasted, may be difficult to see if you like toasting in the dark
Gevi Toaster 4 Slice Led Touchscreen Display
I had to include a high-tech toaster with an LED touchscreen display. This is for those tech-savvy people who love shiny glass control panel touchscreens with lights and progress bars. You have to admit that the Gevi 4 slice toaster has a cool stylish look.
If this is your first experience with touch controls, don’t stress. It is quite easy to understand. The toaster operates as two 2-slice toasters, each with a set of touch buttons on the panel. You have the standard settings for bagels, defrost, reheat and cancel. Bagels will toast the cut side and keep the top side warm. Reheat allows you to heat up a toasted slice without burning it. Cancel stops the toasting at any time.
Being an advanced show-off toaster, it has 2 extra functions. A unique function called ‘The One’ allows you to toast both sides of only one slice in the 2-slice slot. For a show-off factor, the ‘Longer’ function gives you 30 seconds more toastiness.
There are 6 levels of shade, select by a slide bar. As the toast gets darker a light bar will illuminate on the top and disappear from the bottom as the toasting nears completion. This should really impress your guests.
A Quick Look
- 4 slice toaster with independent side controls
- LED Touch screen control panel
- Bagel, defrost, reheat, and cancel functions
- Extra-wide slots for toasting bagels and artisan breads
- 6 shade settings with illuminated bar
- The One and 30 Second Longer functions
- Dual high lift levers
What We Like
- Stylish LED display panel
- Wide slots for bagels, muffins, and artisan breads
- The One and 30 Second Longer functions
- Dual high lift levers
- Fun illuminated bar shows toasting progress
What We Don't Like
- LED display may not suit non-technical people
- Some people prefer extra long slots for artisan breads
Toaster 4 Slice, CUSIMAX Stainless Steel Toaster
The 4 Slice, CUSIMAX Stainless Steel Toaster comes at higher price, but it does offer stylish looks for a modern kitchen. I love that it has simple controls and that they operate separately on either side. You don’t have to be a tech-savvy expert to toast your bread.
The toaster holds 4 slices and has wide 1.4 inch slots for burger buns, croissants, and homemade breads. Each side can operate independently of the other. Select from 6 levels of browning from light to dark, or burnt in this case. Each side can defrost independently. You also have a handy cancel function and a setting for toasting bagels.
There are two crumb trays that pull out separately for easy cleaning.
This toaster has a high rating of 4.7 and most buyers were very happy with their purchase. It is made of stainless steel, which always looks shiny and new. Stainless steel does not tarnish and is easy to clean by wiping with a damp cloth. Under the toaster is a slot for the cord, so you can pack it away easily without cords dangling out of your kitchen closet.
If you want a more retro feel in your kitchen, this model comes in a choice of green or red side panels.
A Quick Look
- 4 slice toaster with independent side controls
- Stainless Steel
- Easy-to-use controls
- Bagel, defrost, and cancel functions
- Extra-wide slots for toasting bagels and artisan breads
- 6 browning settings
- Dual high lift levers
- Separate crumb trays
What We Like
- Stylish compact look
- Wide slots for bagels, muffins, and artisan breads
- Dual high lift levers
- Also comes in a retro green or red design
- Easy to operate
What We Don't Like
- No reheat function
- Some people prefer extra long slots for artisan breads
Smeg 50's Retro Style Aesthetic 4 Slice Long-Slot Toaster
If you are prepared to spend a higher amount of money to toast your bread, Smeg is a world-famous brand name, known for its quality and aesthetics. The Smeg brand was founded in Italy in 1948 by Vittorio Bertazzoni. He lived in a town called Guastalla in the Province of Reggio Emilia, well known for its Parmigiano Reggiano cheese and balsamic vinegar.
Smeg quality is superior and this toaster should last for many years. The features that attract me are the 2 extra-wide, long slots as opposed to 4 separate slots. While you can still toast 4 slices perfectly, you can also toast extra-long slices of artisanal-style breads.
The toaster offers a bagel setting, a reheat function, and a defrost setting. It also has high-lift levers to prevent your fingers from burning when taking out the toast. There are 6 browning levels. The toaster has anti-slip feet that prevent it from slipping off your kitchen counter. For easy cleaning, you have a removable stainless steel crumb tray.
This toaster has a fun retro look and feel and comes in a choice of Pastel Blue, Pastel Green, Pink, or Black. Perfect for a stylish kitchen with a 50’s décor theme.
A Quick Look
- 4 slice toaster with 2 extra-long slots
- Easy-to-use controls
- Bagel, defrost, reheat functions
- Extra-wide slots for toasting bagels and muffins
- 6 browning levels
- Removable crumb tray
- High lift lever
- Cool choice of retro colors
What We Like
- The famous brand name
- Cool looking colors for retro-style kitchens
- Wide slots for bagels, muffins, and artisan breads
- Extra long slots for long slices of artisanal-style breads
- Removable crumb tray
What We Don't Like
- High price may not suit everyone’s budget
- Some people complained that the pop up function throws the toast out and onto your counter
My Top Toaster Suggestions
Best Amazon Basics Budget 4-Slice Toaster – Amazon Basics 4-Slot Toaster, White
Best Value for Money – Mueller UltraToast, Toaster 4 Slice, Long Wide Slots
Best Cool Retro Design – BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster
Best LED Control Panel – Gevi Toaster 4 Slice,Led Display Touchscreen
Best Dual Control 4-slice Toaster – Toaster 4 Slice, CUSIMAX Stainless Steel Toaster
Best 4-Slice Long-Slot Toaster – Smeg 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 4 Slice Long-Slot Toaster
Which Toaster is Best For Me?
If you are looking for value for money, I would recommend the Mueller UltraToast, Toaster 4 Slice, Long Wide Slots. For a cool retro look the BUYDEEM DT640 4-Slice Toaster is a great option at a good price. Do you want a top of the range, expensive model? Then the Smeg 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 4 Slice Long-Slot Toaster is the ultimate show-off kitchen appliance.
Do you feel that a 4-slice toaster is still too small for your family? You may want to consider a Counter Top Toaster. Some of these models can toast up to 8 slices at a time. That means less work for you in the kitchen, and everyone gets hot toast at the same time.
Tasty Toasted Breads From Around The World
Tasty Toasted Breads From Around The World Today, I am taking my taste buds on a trip with a look at tasty toasted breads from…
Novelty Toaster – Hot Dog Toaster
This is such fun that I just cannot resist! My family loves hot dogs and this trendy Hot Dog Toaster takes making hot dogs to…
Novelty Toaster – Star Wars Darth Vader Halo Toaster
VIEW ON AMAZON Star Wars fans never get old – I should know, I am one and I have grandchildren! Bring the Dark Lord into…
Novelty Toaster – West Bend 2-Slice QuikServe Slide Through
A novelty toaster is a fun and unique addition to any kitchen. Not only does it serve its practical purpose of toasting bread, but it…